Midweek Mention... Star Trek: The Next Generation

Welcome back to Bad Dads Film Review! This week, we’re bending time, smashing starships, and looping through one of the most mind-bending episodes of Star Trek: The Next Generation: Season 5, Episode 18 – "Cause and Effect". It’s a perfect example of how sci-fi can take a deceptively simple concept—what if you’re stuck in a time loop?—and turn it into a suspenseful, clever, and surprisingly rewatchable piece of television.
🌀 The Premise: Déjà Vu in Deep Space
The episode opens with an explosive bang—literally—as the USS Enterprise-D is destroyed. Cue the opening credits. Then, everything resets.
We soon realise that the crew is caught in a temporal causality loop, repeating the same few hours over and over again. They have no memory of previous loops, but subtle feelings of déjà vu begin to unsettle them. Dr. Crusher hears the same voices during poker, Data keeps shuffling the cards the same way, and Worf starts getting twitchy about how often the ship’s sensor data is “inconclusive.”
🧠 The Genius of It
Written by Brannon Braga and directed with tight suspense by Jonathan Frakes (a.k.a. Commander Riker), "Cause and Effect" is a masterclass in science fiction structure. Each loop slightly shifts, providing just enough new detail to keep the audience—and the characters—on edge. The growing sense of unease is perfectly balanced with sci-fi problem-solving, leading to Data using the number “3” as a subtle message to his future self in order to break the loop.
And it works! Data realises that Riker’s plan, involving adjusting the ship's yaw, is the correct move—saving the Enterprise and escaping the loop… after 17 days of unknowingly repeating their deaths.
Bonus Trek fact: The ship they collide with? The USS Bozeman, captained by Kelsey Grammer, stuck in the loop for 90 years.
🚀 Why It Stands Out
- Narrative Precision: Few shows handle repetition this well without becoming dull. Here, it’s razor-sharp.
- Creeping Tension: The unsettling deja vu builds atmosphere rather than jumping straight to technobabble.
- Science with Stakes: The loop isn’t just a concept—it’s a matter of life and death. Again and again.
- That Cold Open: Blowing up the Enterprise before the title sequence? Bold.
👨👧👦 A Dad’s Take
It’s smart, eerie, and surprisingly accessible even for those new to Trek. You don’t need deep lore knowledge to enjoy the logic puzzle, the suspense, and the satisfaction of the crew finally cracking the loop. It’s a great episode for older kids or teens curious about sci-fi storytelling.
"Cause and Effect" is one of TNG's most beloved episodes for good reason—it’s an elegant puzzle-box of an episode that proves Star Trek can do high-concept sci-fi with both brains and heart. A loop you won’t mind watching again and again. 🖖🎬💫
We love to hear from our listeners! By which I mean we tolerate it. If it hasn't been completely destroyed yet you can usually find us on twitter @dads_film, on Facebook Bad Dads Film Review, on email at baddadsjsy@gmail.com or on our website baddadsfilm.com.
Until next time, we remain...
Bad Dads
Star Trek Next Gen
Sidey: Are you ready, Dan?
Dan: Do I look ready?
Yeah.
No,
Sidey: Those
glasses. With those glasses,
- You look ready for.
Dan: Thank you. Yeah. New spectacles. Yeah.
Sidey: They do suit you. you.
Dan: yeah.
You know, I'm trying to bring a little intelligence to the show
Cris: Yeah. You look
Reegs: Yeah. you are bringing a little
Dan: yeah. Thank
Sidey: you.
Dan: Thank you.
Sidey: This is the start of,
I
guess loop
Week. as It is. And
we're, we're taking it back to,
A time,
gone by sometime between
87 and 94. Yeah.
For Star Trek Colon, the next generation.
Yeah. And I've gone
for season five, episode 18. Cause and
effect. Yeah.
Anyone familiar with this particular brand
of
Dan: No. I wasn't familiar with this episode before. okay. But I, I was really buoyed to see that Kelsey Grammar was
Sidey: he is, yeah. It's a fleeting appearance.
Dan: was gonna feature, I didn't know, I didn't know at the beginning how much he was gonna feature, but
Sidey: his
name's in light right at
the start, isn't
Dan: Yeah, he, he's, [00:01:00] he's. In it. warp speed. Really?
Reegs: Mm-hmm.
Sidey: Yeah.
This is,
Gonna tell you right now it's the
top rated, episode
according to
Reegs: Star Trek ever. on
Sidey: of, well, certainly of
Star Trek Next generation. According
to
IMDB. Yes.
Dan: Wow. That does
Reegs: that's probably a strong enough, like rep
Sidey: out of 10. User, User recommends that's strong.
Recommend out of the
Dan: gate?
well, I've seen better ones than
Sidey: It's not actually my favorite either. but
this, I would've thought that Picard going Borg would be.
And it's a joint and it gets multiples. But anyway
this starts off with the destruction of the enterprise.
Reegs: Yeah. Well you get captain's log.
Yeah. And the star date, which is 4 5 6 5 2 0.1. Yeah.
Sidey: But it quickly descends into some sort
of chaos.
Something's going
Reegs: pods abandoned
Sidey: Yeah. All hands abandoned ship.
All hands abandoned
ship. Boom. Blows up. Pre-credit bangs
gone.
Dan: Totally
illogical.
Sidey: And, then we go to credits. The classic this is
the
it's a boldly Go where no man has Gone for all women,[00:02:00]
does all that.
And then we cut. and we're back into cap's log.
We've reset. We've Reset. So
it's clear that
it's either, It's either, the,
the
story of
what's happened to
make it blow up or we're in a
loop.
Yeah.
Which
of the, latter. But it starts off with the game of cards.
This is the
officers having their weekly game of cards.
Reegs: What game is it? Is it poker?
Sidey: It's three cards, Brag or something
Dan: that. Yeah. You've got Riker Wharf
Crusher. and
Reegs: Data wearing his little visor. Yeah.
Dan: Yeah.
Reegs: And they're ribbing him about whether he is randomized. The
Dan: Yeah. 'cause he's dealing and dealing a billion miles an
Sidey: Wolf gives him a sort of passive aggressive threat that if they're not randomly you know, shuffled enough. He's gonna like tear him
Reegs: Yeah.
Wharf is, unfortunately he's not got the cards. He's also like only got one approach Really. And he's kind of losing really badly. And it's irking him and Riker and Crusher.
Riker is bluffing. Crusher.
Sidey: Yeah. We get to see this hand played
out. Yeah.
Dan: Yeah.
And
[00:03:00] crusher
Sidey: Crusher has a feeling that he's bullshitting.
Dan: got a feeling that he's bluffing. Then she gets called to the,
Sidey: well, what I would say is that in this. This
far into the, the future of the world in star Trek world, they don't have currency.
There is no physical, you know,
Reegs: No.
Sidey: Presuming because you can create matter through
replicators and all that. So what are
they
gambling for?
Reegs: Just, ch just pride,
Sidey: sexual favors? I think.
Dan: I was gonna say something similar actually. I, I guess it's just the, the things that only you've got,
wearing
Reegs: those like tight.
Sidey: yeah.
Reegs: Trouser
body suit things and that, you know, there is sort of a
a,
Dan: well, they're comfortable
Reegs: sexual tension on the
Dan: They're comfortable, light yet warm, aren't they?
Sidey: of course they all
end up
shagging because,
wharf and
Troy, fuck,
At the end of
season seven, but then Riker and
her have had a thing going on.
They end
up getting married and Picard and Crusher. Fuck,
And
Reegs: and Petro and Deanna,
Troy [00:04:00] and,
isn't, She got a love interest with
Sidey: She,
she Riker first
and then wharf, and at the end of the TV series it's wharf. But then when
we come back to it later on
that her and Raef got back
together and
Reegs: Oh,
Dan: but to be clear, it's not really much about fucking this episode. Is it
Sidey: so much
in this
Reegs: No. This bit is the let's get back to the
episode. She goes down
to, she gets called to sick
Bay because Laforge
has got dizzy spells
and she goes in there to check him up. And she
talks, you know, they go through this rigmarole of establishing his symptoms and what it might be caused by and all this stuff.
And then she, you know, she just says about having deja vu,
Sidey: Very matrixy.
Reegs: And anyway, shrugs it off and, and gives him the spray or whatever it is
that fixes 'em up. And then late,
later that night, she's pruning her flowers. loll
Sidey: and having a glass of sherry or
something
Reegs: just before bed, like necking a glass of sherry and then turning the lights out.
Yeah. And as she does turn the lights out, she suddenly starts hearing all
Sidey: Yeah. 'cause she's a drunk.
Reegs: Yeah,
Dan: exactly what I was
Sidey: Yeah. And I thought this was a bit [00:05:00] weird because it is her that
hears all these voices
where Troy
is the empath and you would've thought
that it would be her that
would be attuned into that first.
But
anyway, it's not.
So it's a kind of crush centric. Plot at this point.
Yeah. And she goes on to,
there's been sort of 10 or 11 reports of these
these voices being
heard
Reegs: Yeah.
Sidey: And then
whilst they're, they go
back to
Reegs: this, they go back to the, they, they all meet up, don't they? And it was just, I think I texted you, the techno babble in this episode.
is Fucking off the charts. I wrote some of it down, but I don't know if this was like typically strong or had
Sidey: they do repeat,
you know, they, they're
consistent with their techno babble, so they don't just make up for one episode. They'll, those will be
things that will,
that
Reegs: they're established in Canon and they have logical effects that impact
other
Sidey: yeah, I mean they're nonsense but they're also
quite fun.
But they're gonna end up back on the
bridge and,
Enson row. who's on the helm.
says that
we've got
Reegs: there's a localized distortion of the space time continuum is what wharf tells them.
And then the power drops out.
Sidey: They say back, back us away
from it.
Back us away.
Carefully. I mean, the
[00:06:00] power's out. Everything's out. The computer's
Reegs: Yeah. And then a federation, Starship
emerges from this like weird rip. in the, in the
space with them powerless, like they throw out suggestions. One is like blow the,
Sidey: well, it's important is it? 'cause Riker says it's
a collision course.
and Riker says.
Why don't we
decompress, decompress the main
shuttle bay. Yeah. The gas fucking explosion
thing will
blow us. Blow that And, and,
Data says,
no dickhead, we need
to do the tractor
beam
and because he's a robot
Android, because like, yes.
Do that. They do that. It
doesn't work. It
collides
with the,
Reegs: the starboard. Nael,
Sidey: Yes. Which explodes and then we get
to hear the, you know, eventually all hands abandoned. the thing that we heard at
the start. Boom.
Dan: Trek no babble on this
Sidey: Yeah. reset back to the
back to the card
game. It
Reegs: It is,
yeah. Well, the captain's log. And then the card game.
Sidey: And everything's now
getting
slightly the, the sort of little lingering
Reegs: Yeah. Well, this time.
Riker doesn't quite go through with his bet. He's got a feeling [00:07:00] that she'll call him on his bluff. And then, you know, there's other things. They, they go through the conversation again with
laforge.
Sidey: She, she,
Reegs: she,
she prunes her flowers
Sidey: that he's gonna come in. She, when the
I think she radios down to sick Ba Say, is
Reegs: laforge, Oh yeah. It's Commander laforge there? And She's like no,
Sidey: wait,
Here he is.
And yeah, that's
Reegs: then late that night, she's doing her flower again and she, she, this time I think she hears the voices and calls Picard, doesn't
Sidey: she? Yeah.
Dan: But around here, which is the character with three ears,
Sidey: dunno
Reegs: which is
Dan: No, you had
Sidey: the final
Dan: you had the
the the,
the
Reegs: oh my God.
Dan: and the
right, and then that final front.
here. Yeah.
Sidey: There's a continuity error here because,
When she calls Bacard and he comes, you
Reegs: they go to the ready
room, the captain's ready
Sidey: he
gives her his recipe for milk with nutmeg.
Reegs: Yes.
Sidey: Which then, so they are destroyed again in this continuity and later on. So this is never, it's never repeated that bit
in this episode,
but in another episode later [00:08:00] on, she gives out the.
The recipe that she's learned from me. card. Forgot. about she, that's a different recipe.
No, it's the
same recipe, but she wouldn't know it because she was destroyed.
Reegs: Oh yes. That version of
Sidey: and that. so they fucked it. They really fucked it. So
zero out
10.
So
yeah, there's that. the next time they're playing the card game this time crush is like she knows what's gonna be dealt.
Yeah. She just goes through and the odds. to that would
be like 7 trillion to one. Which she does. The four cars, then Riker does
four, then
Reegs: Yeah. and, and now there are loads
of reports as well
across as ship Wide that people are reporting that, that,
you know, weirdness is happening and
everybody's experiencing deja vu.
So
Sidey: So this time
I think they get to have an actual meeting.
Like,
In the ready room with all the the senior
leadership.
Reegs: Yeah. Well this is where she forgoes the standard testing on the forge in favor of running an
optical diagnostic. Yeah. And this is where she comes back
with
the results of being positive for a phase shift in
his visual receptors and he's starting to pick up on images Now the forge is visor. that's what's starting to cause his dizziness
Dan: busyness. And They're starting to piece together. They may be in some kind of loop, and they may forget everything. [00:09:00] And so we,
Reegs: and they may
have had these conversations
Sidey: Well, They're
able to, they're able to get a recording of
the noise that she's been hearing.
and then other people have been hearing And
Dan: do you hear noises? No. Good.
Sidey: is able to isolate it. And he says there's like 7,000
different Yeah.
Overlays of the same thing. And then they're able to isolate down to hearing bacard say
all
hands ban it. And they say they know that they're stuck.
and Somehow.
Reegs: Oh, well,
that, well, not somehow sidey, they modulate a deck on emission. Which sets up a resonance in data's onic subprocesses.
Dan: Yes. Exactly.
it's
Reegs: able to leave a, a message for him. Yeah.
In the next
Dan: Let's not dumb it down too much,
Sidey: but it does, it does still take a few iterations of
that.
Before, because
it's, it comes there's various messages left and we get to see that,
when it comes to. The actual
crunch moment. Yeah.
They
still go with the tractor
beam
in
this first
Reegs: They do? Yeah. Because they haven't figured
out what signal
to [00:10:00] leave.
Sidey: Yeah. And then the next
one, it's
Reegs: on the final loop through
They think they, they're all about,
oh, we definitely know the de review. I'm gonna predict the cards. And they all start to predict them and they're wrong. He deals 'em, it's 3, 3,
Sidey: They all get three of a kind. Yeah.
And then we just see millions of different. instances of the
Reegs: number
three keeps, They do a localized scan and it returns something
Dan: all three.
But who is third in command?
Reegs: Well, that's what data realizes on this little loop through. Just as he, as we're getting to the crux of it again, he spots the three pips on pick up on Riker's lapel. and realizes the message that's being
Sidey: he Disobeys
a direct order. he does. I hope he gets court marshaled after this
Dan: I think, data has gone into Picard's bathroom at one point and seen the captain's log, isn't he? Yeah.
Yeah.
Sidey: But they do escape this time. that they, they realize that, well, they,
they,
they get away with
it by doing what
Rikers suggest is, which is to blow up the, [00:11:00] or just
fucking release the,
the, vacuum capacity, blah, blah, blah. and that causes sufficient momentum for them to dodge the Starship.
that's
Dan: so they break the loop.
Sidey: And so they realize that fucking hell. That's an old looking ship.
It's something,
something, something in class.
And they say, fuck, that hasn't been in
service for eight odd years,
Dan: man.
Sidey: So they hail the, the guys, and this is where we see Kelsey Grammar.
He's captain
Gore.
Dan: Yeah.
Reegs: He, well cock
shore As
well, isn't
Sidey: is like, what's up? Lance?
Right? Yeah.
Reegs: guys? Yeah.
Sidey: And you're like, wow. His he's got some retro looking uniform going on there.
Dan: Real Spock.
Sidey: And, they know that they've, they've been stuck in the causality for. Something like nearly 90
years.
90 years.
Yeah.
So everyone they
Dan: only 17 days though.
Sidey: Everyone they know in love is
dead.
And he says to him,
unlucky,
Right? What? I think I suggested beam
Dan: beam aboard. We've gotta have a chat with you. And
Reegs: you. And do we ever see that character again or,
Sidey: No.
Reegs: He's just off, out there having his own
Dan: He's just
Reegs: just a man displaced from time freaked
Dan: out by this [00:12:00] stage. Yeah, so in space it seems there is some kind of time loop where you can just keep going around around, around, around, around and that's what they were caught in.
Sidey: Yeah.
They, they don't know how,
it, how it came
to be or anything.
though. no, the episode's not about that. It's just about the mystery of the destruction of the enterprise.
Dan: Wasn't my favorite Star Trek generation episode. Although I must admit I wasn't a huge fan of this one. I much preferred the old one. I. This one,
It seemed actually not even that clever. This really.
Reegs: I think it is probably suffered because there's been, you know, time loop has become such a massive, you gotta think this was in 87 or 88. This was not, you know, time loop is not
the big
thing that it is now. A whole
Dan: Yeah, I guess so. Yeah. Maybe I, I'm doing it a disservice for that, but I, I did, in, you know, it wasn't torture to watch this. And I'd probably tempt me in to watch another few episodes because I like the [00:13:00] characters. I like the situations and the possibilities of the final frontier.
Reegs: Yeah. Despite the glasses. I'm not a huge trekker, but I have watched Star Trek a bit and I tend to prefer the ones that are a bit more about social issues or political issues, which this one kind of isn't.
It's like pure sci-fi. So. As an episode. This one was, you know, I think it does suffer a little bit, like you say, because the idea has been done so many times since. But it was really good, really neat, good characters like you say. But yeah, preferred other episodes of Star Trek.
Sidey: Chris, you're a huge fan?
Yeah. I know you're, You love sci-fi. and
Cris: I love sci-fi. I love data.
Dan: Yeah,
Reegs: I love,
Cris: Time loops and I
Dan: This was
Cris: found it, I always find it strange when I see Picard walking that he can actually walk.
because I've
Reegs: so used to seeing him
Cris: Yeah. In the chair, in
Sidey: by Dan's chair. Yeah.
Cris: So it's, it's always a bit confusing.
I, I'll have to say, I do remember having this [00:14:00] in when I was a kid on, it was,
it was one of them that, I dunno if it was on purpose or it was one of them TV shows that in, in Romania it was at five o'clock or at half four. So it was like
Sidey: be like five,
Cris: you know, it's shit if it's, they put it at that time,
Sidey: No, it's family friendly.
That's what.
Cris: Okay, whatever. Again, you know, my opinion on sci-fi and that I, I, I don't really I would say out of all the whatever's like older and these kind of sci-fi things, it's probably the one I'm most familiar with because it was every day on and you get home from school. Even if you don't like it, you kind of put the tell on, because it's, that was the, the, the Toes of the Times, and I'm familiar with, I don't remember the guy with a forehead.
What, what's his name? Wolf. Wolf. Wolf.
Sidey: Dawn. Yeah. Yeah, him.
Cris: him. I, I remember the characters and I remember like how they looked like and all that. I couldn't tell you the storyline. I
Sidey: but, well, Wolf was, was, it was a real paradigm shift
because they were like
the classic villain.
Reegs: Yeah, it was a real shock
to have
Sidey: in the original
series.
The cling ones were like the, the [00:15:00] classic villains. Now he's on the,
Cris: in the side.
Dan: we, it wasn't
Reegs: a surefire bet as well that it was gonna
be as massive a success as it was,
you know, that it went on to spawn however many movies and
seasons of
Dan: Well, I always used to confuse. Star
Reegs: There was only two seasons
of the original.
Star Trek wasn't
there?
I think there's only two seasons, It's not very long. So like,
then this came
you know,
that's what expanded
the world. I
Dan: Well
I used to Confused. Star Trek with Star Wars and, you know, it's a Wie mistake really.
Cris: They're
all the same anyway, you know,
it's all the
Reegs: I think Trekker and Wars. would not
Sidey: I really like
Trek this. It's like really, really nice, and optimistic vibe to, to
Star Trek.
Reegs: It's the total opposite of
the way humanity's actually going.
Yeah, I do on Netflix. Did you see the picture when you search for Star Trek, it's Picard going, you know, the classic
Sidey: Well, he's,
I always find it quite funny because he's obviously like a Royal Shakespeare company, like
classic trained,
like
brilliant, brilliant actor
and he is doing all this daft stuff.
Reegs: Yeah. But he's
never a dick
[00:16:00] about it, right? because he, know, he understands.
Sidey: He, it is.
I just
find it funny that he went off to do this Daft TV show
and and
there's episodes, there's one
particular, it
Reegs: It gets a chance to do a
Sidey: lot Oh, don't get wrong. I am fucking all
in.
I love this.
It is brilliant. There's a particular episode
where he's being tortured by the Kardashians.
Reegs: oh, I've had that.
Sidey: Yeah.
I know. But,
And the
guy is saying to him,
how many lights are there? And They're just beaming this light down to
him.
and No matter what he says, it's the wrong answer. And they're torturing him and he is like acting the
shit out
Reegs: I'll
Sidey: with
this guy with like a stupid outfit. You know, it's brilliant. But like you say, he's just totally always been like he's owned
Reegs: it. He's never once, like, I've never heard him say anything negative about the franchise and stuff.
Sidey: He's Come back, to do do more. I'm not so keen on the, the later Picard
series, But,
In the series I, I, this is not my favorite episode. still, I thought this brilliant episode, but the, the BO stuff and the ones with Q. And then
all the, the first contact
Dan: and, and the films. Yeah.
Cris: Is this,
Reegs: The Qing Borg? that was
the better stuff?
Cris: Is this the first time I, I don't, this is a question, but [00:17:00] for me, this was the first time I've ever seen the concept of teleportation.
When you rub the thing and they just teleport through,
Sidey: me up, that sort
Dan: rub your badge.
Cris: Yeah. The, the badge. Yeah.
Sidey: Three to. beam up, that Sort
Cris: It is the first time I've ever seen that in a movie or, or even the, the idea, maybe it's been done before, it's in, in terms of,
Reegs: probably done before, but
Cris: terms of you, you do that and it's a, it's a, it is not just a.
A, a product of people's imagination. You just touch the badge and
Sidey: just, a nice little plot device
to move things
along quickly. to like have them in one place then immediately somewhere.
Cris: Yeah. But it was, it was
Sidey: no, it was cool when I saw it as a
Cris: that was the first time I've ever seen it. So, so obviously I'm, I
Sidey: I think they have been able to teleport quantum.
Reegs: Yeah. Part, I think
qua at a quantum level,
but I don't think that's like
Sidey: Yeah.
But this time next
year,
I so this to me is the strongest possible Recommend,
Reegs: strong
recommend.
Cris: Yeah. 8.9 out of nine.
Dan: The real McCoy.